Comparing Bar Keepers Friend and Ajax can be challenging. Both are popular cleaning products known for their effectiveness.
Cleaning can be a tough job, but the right product makes a huge difference. Bar Keepers Friend and Ajax are two of the most trusted names in household cleaning. Both promise to tackle tough stains and grime. But how do they compare?
This comparison will help you understand their strengths and weaknesses. We will look at their ingredients, uses, and performance. Whether you’re scrubbing a sink or polishing a pot, knowing which product to use will save you time and effort. Let’s dive in and see which cleaner comes out on top!

Brand Histories
Understanding the origins of cleaning products can be fascinating. Two popular brands, Bar Keepers Friend and Ajax, each have unique histories. These stories reveal why they became household names. Let’s explore their beginnings and see what sets them apart.
Bar Keepers Friend Origin
Bar Keepers Friend dates back to 1882. A chemist named George William Hoffman discovered its formula. He noticed its effectiveness in cleaning and polishing. The product quickly gained popularity among bartenders. They used it to keep their bars shining. Hence, the name “Bar Keepers Friend” was born.
The brand continued to grow, reaching more households. It became known for its versatility. People used it for various cleaning tasks. Its unique formulation includes oxalic acid. This ingredient helps remove tough stains. Today, Bar Keepers Friend remains a trusted name in cleaning.
Ajax Background
Ajax entered the market in 1947. The Colgate-Palmolive Company introduced it. Its name comes from a Greek hero. The brand aimed to symbolize strength and power. Ajax quickly became known for its powerful cleaning abilities. It was famous for tackling grease and grime.
Over the years, Ajax expanded its product line. It included powders, liquids, and sprays. The brand focused on providing effective solutions. Ajax products became household staples. Their catchy advertising campaigns helped boost popularity. Ajax remains a strong player in the cleaning market.
Ingredients And Formulations
Understanding the ingredients and formulations of cleaning products is crucial. It helps you choose the right cleaner for your home. Let’s compare Bar Keepers Friend and Ajax.
Bar Keepers Friend Composition
Bar Keepers Friend is known for its powerful cleaning abilities. Its main ingredient is oxalic acid. This acid is derived from plants. It effectively removes rust and hard water stains.
Bar Keepers Friend also contains feldspar. Feldspar is a type of mineral. It provides gentle abrasiveness. This helps scrub surfaces without scratching.
The formula includes surfactants. Surfactants help break down grease and grime. They make cleaning easier and faster.
Bar Keepers Friend does not have bleach. This makes it safe for many surfaces. It is suitable for stainless steel, porcelain, and glass.
Ajax Ingredients
Ajax is popular for its strong cleaning power. Its primary ingredient is sodium dodecylbenzenesulfonate. This is a type of surfactant. It is very effective at cutting through grease.
Ajax also contains calcium carbonate. Calcium carbonate is an abrasive. It helps scrub away tough stains.
Another key ingredient is sodium carbonate. Sodium carbonate acts as a builder. It enhances the cleaning power of the surfactants.
Ajax includes bleach. Bleach helps whiten and disinfect surfaces. It is great for bathrooms and kitchens.
Ajax’s formulation is designed for heavy-duty cleaning. It works well on tiles, sinks, and bathtubs.
Cleaning Power
Bar Keepers Friend and Ajax are popular cleaning products. Bar Keepers Friend works well on tough stains. Ajax excels in general cleaning and disinfecting.
When it comes to household cleaning products, the cleaning power of Bar Keepers Friend and Ajax often sparks debates. Both brands boast impressive capabilities, but how do they really stack up against each other? To help you decide which product is right for your cleaning needs, let’s dive into their effectiveness on different surfaces and their stain removal capabilities.Effectiveness On Different Surfaces
Bar Keepers Friend is a versatile cleaner. It works wonders on stainless steel, porcelain, and ceramic surfaces. I’ve used it to clean my kitchen sink, and the results were outstanding. The shine it brought back to the stainless steel was impressive. Ajax, on the other hand, is known for its power on tiles and grout. It’s great for bathroom cleaning. The grittiness helps scrub away soap scum and grime effectively. But what about delicate surfaces? Bar Keepers Friend is gentle enough to use on glass stovetops without leaving scratches. Ajax can be a bit too abrasive for these surfaces, so you might want to avoid it for delicate tasks.Stain Removal Capabilities
Stubborn stains can be a nightmare. Bar Keepers Friend excels at removing rust, mineral deposits, and hard water stains. I once had a rust stain in my bathtub that wouldn’t budge. A sprinkle of Bar Keepers Friend and a bit of scrubbing, and it was gone. Ajax is a powerhouse when it comes to grease and food stains. If you’ve ever had a baked-on mess in your oven, you know how tough it can be to clean. Ajax tackles these greasy stains head-on, making your life a lot easier. Have you ever wondered why some stains seem impossible to remove? The secret lies in the formulation. Bar Keepers Friend contains oxalic acid, which is excellent for mineral-based stains. Ajax uses bleach, making it effective on organic stains like food and mold. So, which cleaner fits your needs? Think about the surfaces you clean most and the types of stains you encounter. Bar Keepers Friend might be your best friend in the kitchen, while Ajax could be your go-to in the bathroom.User Experience
When it comes to cleaning your kitchen or bathroom, both Bar Keepers Friend and Ajax are popular choices. But how do they compare in terms of user experience? Let’s dive into the nitty-gritty details so you can make an informed decision.
Ease Of Use
Bar Keepers Friend is straightforward to use. You simply sprinkle it on the surface, add a little water, and scrub. The paste-like consistency is easy to manage, making it less messy.
Ajax, on the other hand, is more powdery. It can sometimes puff up into the air when you pour it. This can be slightly inconvenient if you have allergies or respiratory issues.
So, which one do you prefer? The manageable paste of Bar Keepers Friend or the quick-dissolving powder of Ajax? Your choice might depend on your cleaning style and tolerance for a bit of dust.
Safety Measures
Safety is paramount when cleaning. Bar Keepers Friend advises using gloves to protect your skin. The product can be abrasive, so caution is necessary.
Ajax also recommends gloves but tends to be less abrasive. However, it’s wise to avoid contact with your eyes and prolonged skin exposure.
Have you ever experienced skin irritation from a cleaning product? If so, Bar Keepers Friend might require a bit more caution. Always read the labels and follow the safety instructions to protect yourself.
In summary, both products have their unique advantages and minor drawbacks. Whether you prioritize ease of use or safety measures, your choice will ultimately depend on your personal preferences and cleaning habits. So, which one will you try next in your cleaning routine?
Environmental Impact
Bar Keepers Friend and Ajax have different environmental impacts. Bar Keepers Friend is known for its biodegradable ingredients. Ajax contains harsher chemicals that may harm aquatic life.
### Environmental Impact Choosing the right cleaning product can make a big difference for our planet. We all want to keep our homes sparkling clean, but it’s crucial to consider the environmental impact of the products we use. Let’s dive into the eco-friendliness of Bar Keepers Friend and the sustainability of Ajax.Eco-friendliness Of Bar Keepers Friend
Bar Keepers Friend has been around for over a century, but what about its environmental impact? One of the standout features is its biodegradable formula. This means it breaks down naturally, reducing harm to ecosystems. Another plus is that Bar Keepers Friend is phosphate-free. Phosphates can cause algae blooms in water bodies, disrupting aquatic life. By choosing a product without phosphates, you are making a more environmentally conscious choice. It’s also worth mentioning that Bar Keepers Friend uses minimal packaging. Less packaging means less waste. When you finish a can, you’re left with less trash, which is always a good thing.Sustainability Of Ajax
Ajax is a household name, but how does it fare in terms of sustainability? Unfortunately, Ajax contains some ingredients that are less eco-friendly. For instance, it includes phosphates, which can harm aquatic environments. On a positive note, some Ajax products are now made with recyclable packaging. This is a step in the right direction, although there’s room for improvement. Ajax also has a range of products with different formulations. Some are more eco-friendly than others. Always check the label to ensure you’re making the best choice for the environment. Choosing between Bar Keepers Friend and Ajax involves considering their environmental impact. What’s your priority when selecting cleaning products? Are you more concerned about ingredients or packaging? Making small changes in our choices can lead to a big impact on our planet. Let’s make those choices count!
Cost And Availability
Bar Keepers Friend tends to be slightly more expensive than Ajax. Both cleaners are widely available in most stores.
When choosing between cleaning products like Bar Keepers Friend and Ajax, the cost and availability are crucial factors. Both products are popular, but knowing where to find them and how much they cost can save you time and money.Price Comparison
Bar Keepers Friend usually costs slightly more than Ajax. You might find Bar Keepers Friend priced around $5 for a standard size, while Ajax is often closer to $3. However, price can vary depending on the store and location. Some stores offer discounts or bundle deals, especially during sales. Keep an eye out for these promotions to get the best value.Availability In Stores And Online
Both Bar Keepers Friend and Ajax are widely available in grocery stores, big-box retailers, and online marketplaces. In stores, you can typically find them in the cleaning supplies aisle. However, availability can vary; Bar Keepers Friend might be more common in specialty stores, while Ajax is usually found in most supermarkets. Online shopping offers convenience, but check shipping costs. Sites like Amazon, Walmart, and Target stock both products, often with reviews to help you decide. Have you ever found yourself needing a cleaner but not finding the brand you prefer? It’s worth considering availability next time you shop.Consumer Reviews And Feedback
Choosing the right cleaning product for your home can be challenging. Bar Keepers Friend and Ajax are two popular choices that many consumers compare. To help you make an informed decision, let’s look at what users have to say about both products.
Positive Reviews
Many consumers rave about the effectiveness of Bar Keepers Friend. They highlight its ability to remove tough stains from various surfaces like stainless steel, porcelain, and glass. Users often mention that it works wonders on burnt pots and pans.
Ajax also garners positive feedback for its versatility. Consumers appreciate its powerful formula that can tackle grease and grime with ease. It’s a favorite for cleaning kitchen and bathroom surfaces, particularly because it leaves a fresh scent behind.
Both products are praised for their affordability and ease of use. Customers frequently mention how a small amount goes a long way, making either product a cost-effective choice for regular cleaning tasks.
Common Complaints
Despite its popularity, Bar Keepers Friend does have its share of criticism. Some users find the powder version a bit messy to use. Others note that it can be too abrasive for delicate surfaces, potentially causing scratches.
Ajax is not without its downsides either. A common complaint is its strong smell, which some users find overwhelming. Additionally, a few consumers report that it requires more scrubbing effort compared to other cleaners.
Both products have been noted for their potential to cause skin irritation. It’s advisable to use gloves when handling them to avoid any adverse reactions.
Have you tried Bar Keepers Friend or Ajax? What has your experience been like? Your insights could help others make the right choice for their cleaning needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Bar Keepers Friend Powder The Same As Ajax Powder?
No, Bar Keepers Friend powder is not the same as Ajax powder. They have different ingredients and cleaning purposes.
What Is Better Than Bar Keepers Friends?
Bon Ami is considered better by some users. It is non-toxic, gentle, and effective on various surfaces.
What Should You Not Use Bar Keepers Friend On?
Avoid using Bar Keepers Friend on gold, silver, pewter, anodized aluminum, mirrored surfaces, and lacquered wood. It can damage these materials.
What’s Better Than Ajax?
Fetch API is better than Ajax. It offers a simpler syntax and better error handling. Plus, it supports promises for asynchronous operations.
Conclusion
Choosing between Bar Keepers Friend and Ajax depends on your needs. Both are strong cleaners. Bar Keepers Friend works great on tough stains. Ajax is good for everyday cleaning. Each has its strengths. Consider what surfaces you clean most. This will help you decide.
Try both to see which suits you better. Happy cleaning!